Comparison of NAA XRF and ICP-OES Methods on Analysis of Heavy Metals in Coals and Combustion Residues

Agus Taftazani(1*), Roto Roto(2), Novitasari Restu Ananda(3), Sri Murniasih(4)

(1) Center for Accelerator Science and Technology, National Nuclear Energy Agency
(2) Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Universitas Gadjah Mada
(3) Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Universitas Gadjah Mada
(4) Center for Accelerator Science and Technology, National Nuclear Energy Agency
(*) Corresponding Author


Heavy metals in the samples of coals and combustion residues (bottom ash and fly ash) from Pacitan coal-fired power plant (CPP) have been identified by using NAA, XRF, and ICP-OES methods. This research was aimed to understand the analysis results correlation coefficient (R) and determine the enrichment ratio (ER) value of the samples by using three analysis methods. The results showed 10 elements have been simultaneously detected in all samples. The correlation coefficient of analysis results of metals content in coals by using NAA-XRF, XRF-ICP OES and with ICPOES-NAA methods gives R2£1 respectively. The correlation coefficient of analysis results of metals content in bottom ash and fly ash by using the methods of NAA-XRF, XRF-ICPOES, and ICPOES-NAA gained R2»1 respectively. ICP-OES method was most satisfactory in this study. The value of ER for identified metals by using the three methods in the samples of bottom ash and fly ash yielded the value over one, and ER value of fly ash was greater in comparison to the bottom ash.


bottom ash; fly ash; NAA; XRF; ICP-OES

Full Text:

Full Text PDF


[1] Malik, M., Soni, N.K., Kanagasabapathy, K.V., Prasad, M.V.R., and Satpathy, K.K., 2016, Characterisation of fly ash from coal-fired thermal power plants using energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometry, Sci. Rev. Chem. Commun., 6 (4), 91–101.

[2] Smolka-Danielowska, D., 2006, Heavy metals in fly ash from a coal-fired power station in Poland, Pol. J. Environ. Stud., 15 (6), 943–946.

[3] Zhong, H., Zhao, Y., Muntean, M., Zhang, L., and Zhang, J., 2016, A high-resolution regional emission inventory of atmospheric mercury and its comparison with multi-scale inventories: A case study of Jiangsu, China, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 15119–15134.

[4] Guttikunda, S.K., and Jawahar, P., 2014, Atmospheric emissions and pollution from the coal-fired thermal power plants in India, Atmos. Environ., 92, 449–460.

[5] Mujuru, M., McCrindle, R.I., Botha, B.M., and Ndibewu, P.P., 2009, Multi-element determinations of N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) coal slurries using ICP-OES, Fuel, 88 (4), 719–724.

[6] Tiwari, M., Sahu, S.K., Bhangare, R.C., Ajmal, P.Y., and Pandit, G.G., 2014, Elemental characterization of coal, fly ash, and bottom ash using an energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence technique, J. Appl. Radiat. Isot., 90, 53–57.

[7] Patra, K.C., Tapash, R., Rautray, T.R., Tripathy, B.B., and Nayak, P., 2012, Elemental analysis of coal and coal ash by PIXE, J. Appl. Radiat. Isot., 70 (4), 612–616.

[8] Lim, J.M., Jeong, J.H., and Lee, J.H., Instrumental neutron activation analysis of coal and its combustion residues from a power plant, 2013, J. Radioanal. Nucl. Chem., 298 (1), 201–208.

[9] Tuning, S.S., and Samin, 2012, Test of Homogeneity and Stability of SRM Sodium Zirconate Candidate with XRF Method, Proceedings of the Scientific Meeting and Presentation on Basic Research in Nuclear of the Science and Technology, Center for Accelerator Technology and Process Materials - BATAN Yogyakarta, 176–183.

[10] Musawwa, M.M., Taftazani, A., and Riyanto, 2013, Metal Distribution Fe, Ca, Ti, Ba, Sr, Zr and in Coal and Combustion Residues of Cilacap Coal Fired Plant using XRF, Proceedings of the National Seminar on Nuclear Analysis Techniques, Yogyakarta, 104–112.

[11] Anonymous, Standard test method for determination of major and minor elements in coal, coke, and solid residues from combustion of coal and coke by inductively coupled plasma—atomic emission spectrometry, ASTM D6349-13.

[12] Anonymous, Test methods for determination of trace elements in coal, coke, & combustion residues from coal utilization processes by inductively coupled plasma atomic emission, inductively coupled plasma mass, & graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry, ASTM D6357-11.

[13] González, A.G., and Herrador, M.A., 2007, A practical guide to analytical method validation, including measurement uncertainty and accuracy profiles, TrAC, Trends Anal. Chem., 26 (3), 227–238.

[14] Sutcu, E.C., and Karayigit, A.I., 2015, Mineral matter, major and trace element content of the Afşin–Elbistan coals, Kahramanmaraş, Turkey, Int. J. Coal Geol., 144-145, 111–129.

[15] Ketris, M.P., and Yudovich, Y.E., 2009, Estimations of Clarkes for Carbonaceous biolithes: World averages for trace element contents in black shales and coals, Int. J. Coal Geol., 78 (2), 135–148.

[16] Wang, J., Yamada, O., Nakazato, T., Zhang, Z.G., Suzuki, Y., and Sakanishi, K., 2008, Statistical analysis of the concentrations of trace elements in a wide diversity of coals and its implications for understanding elemental modes of occurrence, Fuel, 87 (10-11), 2211–2222.

[17] Meravi, N., and Prajapati, S.K., 2014, Effects of heavy metals/metalloids present in fly ash from coal fired thermal power plant on photosynthetic parameters of Mangifera indica, Environ. Skep. Crit., 3 (4), 88–92.

[18] Ghodke, S., Kumar, R., Singh, N., and Khandelwal, H., 2012, Estimation of greenhouse gas emission from Indian coal based thermal power plant, IOSR J. Eng., 2 (4), 591–597.

[19] Kim, H.K., and Lee, H.K., 2015, Coal bottom ash in field of civil engineering: A review of advanced applications and environmental considerations, KSCE J. Civ. Eng., 19 (6) 1802–1818.

[20] Damastuti, E., Sulaeman, A., and Santoso, M., 2014, Development of environmental reference material candidate of coal fly ash for air quality monitoring implementation: I. Homogeneity, stability and characterization, JASES, 9 (1), 17–26.

[21] Murniasih, S., and Taftazani. A., 2017, Comparison of the results of two laboratory analysis using different methods, Comparison of two laboratory analysis results using different methods, Ganendra Nucl. Sci. Technol. J., 20 (1), 23–30.

[22] Dai, S., Zhao, L., Peng, S., Chou, C.L., Wang, X., Zhang, Y., Li, D., and Sun, Y., 2010, Abundances and distribution of minerals and elements in high-alumina coal fly ash from the Jungar Power Plant, Inner Mongolia, China, Int. J. Coal. Geol., 81, 320–332.

[23] Bhangare, R.C., Ajmal, P.Y., Sahu, S.K., Pandit, G.G., and Puranik, V.D., 2011, Distribution of trace elements in coal and combustion residues from five thermal power plants in India, Int. J. Coal. Geol., 86 (4), 349–356.


Article Metrics

Abstract views : 4536 | views : 4003

Copyright (c) 2017 Indonesian Journal of Chemistry

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.


Indonesian Journal of Chemistry (ISSN 1411-9420 /e-ISSN 2460-1578) - Chemistry Department, Universitas Gadjah Mada, Indonesia.

Analytics View The Statistics of Indones. J. Chem.