Multi-Year Program under Budget Constraints Using Multi-Criteria Analysis

Surya Adiguna(1*), Dewanti Dewanti Dewanti(2), JB Odoki(3)

(1) Ministry of Publik Work and Public Housing , Jakarta
(2) Gadjah Mada University
(3) Department of Road Management and Engineering, University of Birmingham,
(*) Corresponding Author


Road investment appraisal requires joint consideration of multiple criteria which are related to engineering, economic, social and environmental impacts. The investment consideration could be based on the economic analysis but however for some factors, such as environmental, social, and political, are difficult to quantify in monetary term. The multi-criteria analysis is the alternative tool which caters the requirements of the issues above. The research, which is based on 102 class D and class E paved road sections in Kenya, is about to optimize road network investment under budget constraints by applying a multi-criteria analysis (MCA) method and compare it with the conventional economic analysis. The MCA is developed from hierarchy structure which is considered as the analytical framework. The framework is based on selected criteria and weights which are assigned from Kenya road policy. The HDM-4 software is applied as decision-making tool to obtain the best investment alternatives and road work programs from both MCA and economic analysis. The road work programs will be the results from the analysis using both MCA and economic analysis within HDM-4 software to see the difference and compare the results between both programs. The results from MCA show 51 road sections need periodic work, which is overlay or resealing. Meanwhile, 51 others need rehabilitation or reconstruction. The five years road work program which based on economic analysis result shows that it costs almost Kenyan Shilling (KES) 130 billion to maintain the class D and E paved road in Kenya. Meanwhile, the MCA only requires KES 59.5 billion for 5 years program. These results show huge margin between two analyses and somehow MCA result provides more efficient work program compared to economic analysis.


Multi-criteria analysis, road works program, budget constraints, highway development and maintenance management

Full Text:



ADB, 2010. Technical Assistance Consultant’s Report, 2010. Republic of Indonesia: Regional Roads Development Project. [Online]
Available at:
[Accessed 16 July 2016].

Adiguna, S., 2017. Multi-Year Programme under Budget Constraints using Multi-Criteria Analysis , Yogyakarta: Master Thesis. Faculty of Engineering, Universitas Gadjah Mada.

Aprilischa, A., Muthohar, I. & Moxon, R., 2015. Evaluation of the Alternative Railway Connection Access at Jakarta Soekarno-Hatta International Airport. Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum, 1(1), pp. 1-10. doi: 10.22146/jcef.22724

Cafiso, S. et al, 2002. Multi-Criteria Analysis Method for Pavement Maintenance Management. [Online]
Available at:
[Accessed 27 June 2016].

DFID, 1998. Overseas Road Note 15. Guidelines for the design and operation of road management systems. Berkshire: Department for International Development.

Evdorides, H., 2016. Management Process. Road Asset Management. University of Birmingham.

Heggie, I. G. & Vickers, P., 1998. Commercial Management and Financing of Roads.. [Online]
Available at:
[Accessed 20 July 2016].

Hiep, D., 2006. HDM-4 Application for Management and Maintenace of Road Networks in Vietnam: Pitfalls and Future Directions. [Online]
Available at:
[Accessed 5 July 2016].

KENHA., 2016. Kenya National Highways Authority. Road Classification. [Online]
Available at:
[Accessed 4 August 2016].

Kenya Rural Roads Authority, 2016. Roads Category. [Online]
Available at:
[Accessed 4 August 2016].

Odoki, J. B. & Kerali, H. R., 2006. Analytical Framework and Model Descriptions. Highway Development and Management Series. International Study of Highway Development and Management, 2nd edn, vol. 4. Paris: World Road Association PIARC.Paris: World Road Association PIARC.

Odoki, J. & Odongo, 2016. Case Study: HDM-4 Adaptation for Analysing Kenya Roads. [Online]
Available at:
[Accessed 1 July 2016].

Robinson, R., 2008. Restructuring Road Institutions, Finance and Management, Volume 1: Concepts and Principles. United Kingdom: University of Birmingham.

Stannard, E., 2016. HDM-4 Introduction. Road Economic and Financing. University of Birmingham.


Article Metrics

Abstract views : 578 | views : 869


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2017 Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum

The content of this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
ISSN 5249-5925 (online) | ISSN 2581-1037 (print)
Jl. Grafika No.2 Kampus UGM, Yogyakarta 55281
Email :
Web Analytics JCEF Stats